General Approach for Modeling Bacterial TMDLs on the Texas Gulf Coast

Stephanie L. Johnson, CRWR

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

BACKGROUND

LOAD DURATION CURVES

FUTURE WORK

PRIMARY CONTACT

INTRODUCTION

Research is currently being conducted at the Center for Research in Water Resources to develop a general method for modeling bacterial total maximum daily loads (TMDLs) along the Middle Bay System of the Texas Gulf Coast.  Figure 1 shows the location of these bays and their corresponding watersheds.

Figure 1:  Six Texas Coastal Watersheds with Bacterial TMDL Studies

BACKGROUND

The TMDL program is based on regulations stated under Section 303 of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Clean Water Act.  Under these regulations, states are required to list waterbodies that do not meet water quality standards; for each of these waterbodies a TMDL must be developed.  The TMDL is an allocation of pollutant loading (to all contributors within a watershed) based on the calculated total amount of pollutant that a waterbody can receive while still meeting water quality standards.  The state agency in charge of TMDLs in Texas is the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ).

CRWR's previous work on this topic has concentrated on the Copano Bay watershed, located at the southern end of the Middle Bay network (see Figure 2). 

Figure 2: Copano Bay Watershed

LOAD DURATION CURVES

Load duration curves are one method that has been used to successfully develop TMDLs for bacterial impairments.  A load duration curve is a graph depicting the percentage of time that a given load (CFU/day of bacteria, for example) is equaled or exceeded.  The pollutant load at a given point in a stream is calculated by multiplying the flow by the pollutant concentration and a conversion factor; the result is a pollutant load (typically load per day).  Target loading curves are created by combining a flow duration curve with the water quality standard for the parameter of interest.  Measured pollutant concentrations are then converted to loads and added to the curve.  A point falling above the target curve is out of compliance; a point falling below the curve is in compliance.  An example load duration curve is shown in Figure 3.

 Figure 3:  Sample Load Duration Curve

 

TCEQ has recently started using the load duration curve method for calculating bacterial TMDLs.  This method is attractive because it effectively integrates flow regimes into TMDL analyses, clearly communicates data through a method that is understandable to the general public and has historically been acceptable to the EPA.  A webscraper tool has been developed within the Excel software to automatically compute duration curves for a given water quality monitoring site within the state of Texas.  This tool performs a web query to retrieve flow and water quality data from US Geological Survey (USGS) and TCEQ websites.  The data is manipulated within the spreadsheet to create the load duration curve, plot the existing water quality data, and calculate the percent load reduction needed to meet water quality standards.  By calling on data retrieving capabilities, this tool is able to automatically create duration curves and calculate load reductions in a matter of minutes. A general picture of the process is shown below in Figure 4.

 

Figure 4: Load Duration Curve Tool

FUTURE WORK

 

Future work on this topic will be to extend load duration curve modeling from a riverine analysis to include bacterial loadings to the bays.  Methods will be developed to account for bay hydraulics and tidal exchanges, while keeping the analysis simple enough for use in preliminary TMDL development.  Modeling methods that have proven successful in the Copano Bay watershed will be generalized for use across the Middle Bay system.  The use of webservices will be expanded in an attempt to semi-automate the general modeling method; the result will be a regional approach for modeling bacterial TMDLs in a user-friendly, easily produced format.

 

PRIMARY CONTACT

For more information on this project, please contact:

Stephanie L. Johnson, P.E.

Ph.D. Candidate
Center for Research in Water Resources
University of Texas at Austin

email: sljohnson@mail.utexas.edu


These materials may be used for study, research, and education, but please credit the authors and the Center for Research in Water Resources, The University of Texas at Austin. All commercial rights reserved. Copyright 2007 Center for Research in Water Resources.